Very happy with the bag so far. 3mm padding is thin, really thin, maybe a bit thinner than I anticipated. However, the bag is clearly designed to be a day-bag rather than a travel-bag and for this purpose I think the padding is sufficient and might even come in handy when you try to pack your whole quiver in your car. One thing that i would say is slightly odd is the length. My fish board is thick as, plenty wide and 5'10" long , while another 2-3 inches in length would make it a lot easier to close the zip the bag is very very wide, at least 6 inch wider than my board.
Anyway, buy it if you need a very affordable day-bag with little fuss and your board is 5'09" rather than 5'10,2".